Triple Crown champion Justify, who burst onto the horse racing scene in February, has left just as quickly. The 3-year-old colt was retired Wednesday after just 112 racing days and six races to become the only undefeated Triple Crown champion.
Is justify the best horse of 2018?
- Nonetheless. he stood off a strong bid from 2018 champion older male Accelerate, who won five Grade 1 races during the season, to become the 2018 American Horse of the Year. Justify was rated at 125 pounds on the 2018 Longines World’s Best Racehorse Rankings, tops among 3-year-olds and tied for eighth overall.
Who owns Justify the horse?
Who owns Justify? Justify was purchased for $500,000 at Keeneland’s 2016 September Yearling Sale by a partnership of multiple groups, with WinStar Farm being the majority owner.
How old is Zenyatta horse?
Zenyatta, a 17-year-old daughter of Street Cry who resides at Lane’s End Farm in Versailles, Ky., is the dam of four registered foals, none victorious. Her first two, Cozmic One (Bernardini ) and Ziconic (Tapit ), have both been retired to second careers as off-track Thoroughbreds.
How many foals does Justify have?
Justify has 90 offspring cataloged for that sale. For more, watch our BH+ video from the start of the season—Sales Spotlight: Justify’s First Yearlings.
Was Justify disqualified from the Kentucky Derby?
Justify faced disqualification from his victory in the Santa Anita Derby that would cost his owners — a partnership of wealthy interests — their share of the $600,000 first-place purse. If the complaint was ruled on quickly enough, it would have made Justify ineligible for the Kentucky Derby.
How much is Justify worth?
Justify is reportedly worth $60 million following his Triple Crown win. Forbes has estimated that once retired, Justify could demand an initial $100,000 stud fee – giving him a $60 million value based solely on breeding fees if he were to cover 150 mares per breeding season for four years.
How much is WinStar farm worth?
WinStar regularly ranks among the Top 10 North American breeders and has been in the Top Five by earnings each year since 2014. WinStar topped all breeders in 2018 with $8.6 million in earnings. 6
How tall is Justify?
At 16.3 hands, Justify isn’t the tallest horse Bob Baffert has trained, but he’s up there.
Is American Pharoah related to Secretariat?
American Pharoah is a descendant of Secretariat through his dam, Littleprincessemma. Secretariat is his great, great, great grandfather on his maternal side. Secretariat isn’t the only successful horse in American Pharoah’s pedigree. His sire, Pioneerof the Nile, was second in the Kentucky Derby in 2009.
How many foals has Zenyatta?
Zenyatta has had two foals to race and one preparing for her first start: Cozmic One (2012), Ziconic (2013), and an unraced 2017 filly by Medaglia d’Oro named Zellda.
How many babies does Zenyatta?
Zenyatta has delivered four foals, and this was the second to die, both sired by War Front. Less than two years ago Z Princess, the first filly born to Zenyatta, was euthanized after a farm accident. She was playing with other young horses when one crashed into her and broke her back.
How many hands is Zenyatta horse?
At maturity, Zenyatta’s height was reported by various sources at between 17 hands (68 inches, 173 cm) and 17.2 hands (70 inches, 178 cm) at the withers. Her stride was estimated at 26 feet (7.9 m). Her conformation is generally good with a “tremendous” shoulder and hip, but “less than ideal” ankles.
What was Secretariat’s stud fee?
Secretariat was sold to a breeding syndicate for a then-record $6.08 million. Then there was Secretariat at the 1973 Belmont Stakes. He carried a lot more than jockey Ron Turcotte when he went to the gate a 1-to-10 favorite. He had the weight of Secretariat Mania on his back.
Where is Justify today?
Where is Justify? As of Sept. 17, 2018, Justify resides at Coolmore America’s Ashford Stud Farm in Versailles, Kentucky. Justify will stand at the farm in 2019 for the first season of his stud career.
How much did American Pharoah breeding rights sell for?
The court filing reveals that two rights were sold to LNJ Foxwoods in December 2018 for a total of $750,000, while the remaining seven rights were sold to Orpendale through the first half of 2019 for a combined $2.55 million.
It’s a Girl: First Foal by Justify Born in Kentucky
The first reported foal from the 2018 Triple Crown winner’s first crop has been identified. Justify was born on January 3 at Amaroo Farm in Kentucky, according to the farm’s owners, who announced the birth the following day. ‘Exchange Ratemare’ is the dam of the bay filly, who is the first foal to be born from her. Foreign Affair is a half sister to So Perfect, a Scat Daddy filly who finished third in the group 3 and first in the group 1. Sir Barton, who won the Kentucky Derby, Preakness Stakes, and Belmont Stakes in 1919, was the first Triple Crown winner in America, and Audley was the trainer who stood him.
While Audley is located near Berryville, Virginia, the filly will be designated as a Virginia-bred.
ET on Friday, only a few days before she was scheduled to arrive.
“The most important thing is that the foal is healthy and happy.
- She’ll return to Virginia to be registered, and the mare will remain in the state to produce a Virginia-bred foal the following year.
- The opportunity to purchase a mare carrying a foal from the 2018 Triple Crown winner’s first crop, according to McDiarmid, filled a vacuum in their stable.
- “It was our first time breeding with Justify, and sadly our mare did not produce a foal, so we were on the lookout for another.
- She comes from a young family that has had a lot of assistance, so she has a wonderful pedigree.
- According to McDiarmid, “We were searching for a sire that was extremely globally appealing, and More Than Ready has shown to be that sire time and time again.” The fact that we haven’t bred to him in quite some time makes us quite excited.
- There are several of them, including a grade 1 winner.
- Justify stood his first season at Coolmore’s Ashford Stud in Kentucky in 2019 for a cost of $150,000, which was publicized at the time.
When Justify was bred, he produced a record-breaking 41 grade 1-winning mares, the highest number ever produced by a North American stud. His price for 2020 remains at $150,000, according to his website.
Justify – Triple Crown Winner 2018
In the United States, the Triple Crown consists of three thoroughbred horse races for three-year-old horses held in May and early June of each year. Achieving the Triple Crown in horse racing is often regarded as one of the most difficult feats in the sport, if not all of sports championships. A three-year-old horse must first win the Kentucky Derby, then two weeks later win the Preakness Stakes, and then three weeks later win the Belmont Stakes in order to complete the arduous three-race program.
Kellie Reilly contributed to this article. Justify, the most recent Triple Crown champion, bucked tradition twice over: he did not run at two and went on to conclude his stratospheric career undefeated. Justify, a Septemberyearling who was bred by the father-daughter partnership of John and Tanya Guntherat Glennwood Farm, sold for $500,000 at the Keeneland Septemberyearling sale. He was a member of Scat Daddy’s final crop, which was his first breeding season. Simply put, WinStar Farm and China Horse Club were the driving forces behind Justify’s ownership consortium, which included SF Racing.
- That premiere didn’t happen until February 18, 2018, which was too late for the team to win the Triple Crown by historical standards.
- However, Hall of Fame trainer Bob Baffert, whose American Pharoah broke the Triple Crown drought in 2015, was able to get the most out of Justify in the shortest amount of time possible.
- In order to qualify for the Kentucky Derby, he only had one shot – the Santa AnitaDerby– and he punched his ticket in front-running fashion.
- As far as managing speed was concerned, the Belmont was a relative saunter.
- TwinSpires: Justify Horse Profile Justify the Horse Profile, according to BetAmerica.
Simply said, Justify had his racing debut on February 18, 2018, which was much too late to contemplate preparing him for the Kentucky Derby, according to traditional thinking. Justify won the Triple Crown 111 days later, becoming the 13th American to do so, and just the second to do it while remaining undefeated in the series (the first wasSeattle Slew). Due to a recurrent ankle ailment, the strapping chestnut was expected to pursue the Breeders’ Cup Classic (USA-G1) following his Belmont Stakes victory, but he was forced to withdraw from racing on July 25, 2018, and has not raced since.
The champion older male Accelerate, who won five Grade 1 races throughout the season, made a strong attempt to win the 2018 American Horse of the Year, but he was able to hold off the challenge. The following is his race record:6 starts; 6 victories; zero seconds; zero thirds; US$3,798,000 in 2018:
- The Belmont Stakes Presented by NYRA Bets (USA-G1, 12FD, Belmont)
- The Preakness Stakes (USA-G1, 9.5FD, Pimlico)
- The Kentucky Derby Presented by Woodford Reserve (USA-G1, 10FD, Churchill Downs)
- The Santa Anita Derby (USA-G1, 9FD, Santa Anita)
- And the Kentucky Derby Presented by Woodford Reserve (USA-G1, 10FD, Churchill Downs).
- In 2018, the Eclipse Award was given to the American Horse of the Year
- In 2018, the Eclipse Award was given to the American champion 3-year-old male.
Assessments The 2018 Longines World’s Best Racehorse Rankings placed Justify at 125 pounds, placing him first among 3-year-olds and tied for seventh overall in the rankings. According to reports, Justify has a 16.3 hand advantage as an individualA chestnut. He possesses a massive, muscular body as well as exceptional agility, and he is a superb mover. Ses main weapon on the track was his fast cruising speed, which usually resulted in him being placed in the lead or very close to the top of the standings.
- In the opinion of his associates, he is extremely brilliant and eager to learn, but he is also dominating and has a tendency to bite people.
- Justify was foaled in Kentucky and was bred by John Gunther.
- Bob Baffert was in charge of his training.
- Several media publications, including ESPN and other outlets, said that the agreement was for up to US$75 million, however this was never confirmed.
- Prospector, a two-time American champion sire and nine-time American champion broodmare sire, is inbred 5x3x5 to Justify, who is inbred 5x3x5 to Mr.
- His other inbreds include the mare Narrate, who is 5×5 to the 1970 English Triple Crown winner, 1986 English champion sire, and two-time American champion broodmare sireNijinsky II, as well as 4×5 to the sire Nijinsky II.
- Justify’s stumbling block Stage Magic finished third in the Grade 3 division on the track.
- All three wins were produced from the unraced dam of the sisters, who is out of Grade 3 winner Voodoo Lily (by Baldski), one of three stakes winners produced from the mare.
- Books and other forms of media
- The book Justify: 111 Days to Triple Crown Glory tells the story of Justify. The book, written by Lenny Shulman and including a foreword by Steve Haskin, was published by Triumph Books in 2019
- The author is Lenny Shulman. According to Ed Bowen’s The Lucky 13: The Champions of America’s Triple Crown of Horse Racing (2019, Lyon Press), Justify is the thirteenth of the American Triple Crown winners to win the race.
- Justify is the most lightly raced Triple Crown victor in American history, having competed in only six races prior to winning the Belmont, which turned out to be his final one. Justify became the first horse since Apollo in 1882 to win the Kentucky Derby without having raced at the age of two. Previously, American Pharoah was the most lightly raced horse to win the Triple Crown, as the Belmont was his eighth start
- He was also one of the Triple Crown winners with the fewest lifetime starts (11)
- And American Pharoah had previously been the most lightly raced horse to win the Triple Crown. Justify became the first horse to win the Kentucky Derby with only three prior races since Big Brown did it in 2008. He is the fifth of Bob Baffert’s six Kentucky Derby winners, matching him with legendary Calumet Farm trainer Ben Jones for the most Derby victories by a trainer. Silver Charm (1997), Real Quiet (1997), War Emblem (2002), American Pharoah (2015), and Authentic (1998) were the other films (2020). When Medina Spirit finished first in the 2021 Kentucky Derby, Baffert appeared to have a record-breaking seventh Derby winner, but the victory was revoked after the colt tested positive for the corticosteroid bethmethasone. Justify’s victory in the Belmont Stakes made Baffert one of only two men in history to train two American Triple Crown winners. One of the other trainers was “Sunny Jim” Fitzsimmons, who trained Gallant Fox(1930) and Omaha(1935)
- Justify’s Triple Crown sweep also marked the first time that a 52-year-old jockey had won the American Triple Crown
- According to Elliott Walden of WinStar Farm(“Just Spectacular,” Lenny Shulman, June 16, 2018), the name “Justify” was given to farm manager Amy Nave, who was in A piece by New York Times journalist Joe Drape, published on September 11, 2019, said that the horse Justify had tested positive for the prohibited chemical scopolamine after competing in the Santa Anita Derby. The Association of Racing Commissioners International has classed Scopolamine as a 4C drug, which is the least dangerous classification among prohibited substances. Veterinarians have provided inconsistent findings on the chemical’s possible impact on horse performance. Although the drug positive was submitted to the California Horse Racing Board on April 18, according to the story, trainer Bob Baffert did not get notification from the CHRB until April 26. Baffert subsequently used his authority to request that a part of the sample be sent for testing to a certified independent laboratory, which was done on May 1, according to the terms of the agreement. The positive result was verified by an independent lab, but the data were not received until May 8, by which time Justify had won the Kentucky Derby and the race was over (for which he would not have been eligible had he been disqualified from his Santa Anita Derby win). As a result of this report, the CHRB stated that it did not have enough time to conduct a thorough investigation prior to the Kentucky Derby and that the positive test resulted most likely from environmental contamination with jimsonweed, a plant that naturally contains scopolamine and has been found inadvertently combined with horse feed and straw intended for horse bedding. Justify’s drug tests following all three Triple Crown races were negative. The Santa Anita stewards conducted a review of the CHRB’s judgment on December 9, 2020, and the results of the Santa Anita Derby remained intact. Justify’s first foal was a filly out of the Exchange Rate mare Foreign Affair, who was born on January 3, 2020, and was named Justify. Lord Audley Farm, which was responsible for breeding Sir Barton, the first American Triple Crown winner, was responsible for breeding the filly as well.
Photographer’s credit Tim Stephansen captured this image at the Ashford Stud in 2019. Permission has been granted to use. The most recent update was made on February 21, 2022.
- The best son of the spectacular stallion SCAT DADDY, who is also a promising sire of sires
- This is the finest son of SCAT DADDY, a magnificent stallion who is quickly becoming a leading sire of sires.
Six victories by over 24 lengths and approximately $3.8 million from seven to twelve furlongs on fast to sloppy tracks. In 2018, the Beyer Speed Figures reached five triple digits. To locate a finer example of the Thoroughbred breed would necessitate a lengthy search. Justify emanates strength. When he’s on the field, he delivers the whole package: speed, stride, and endurance.” -The Blood-Horse is a fictional character created by author Robert E. Howard. “a towering muscular Adonis of a horse,” writes the author.
“Justify could have run on any surface; the great ones, however, bring their track with them wherever they go.” Super-talented horses can take on any challenge.
“We believe he has the potential to be an outstanding sire.” -Ned Toffey, Spendthrift Farm’s General Manager His first crop yearlings in 2021 sold for $200,000,000, $1,550,000, $950,000, $825,000, $775,000, $750,000, $750,000, $750,000, $750,000, $750,000, $750,000, $750,000, $750,000, $750,000, $750,000, $750,000, $750,000, $750,000, $750,000, $750,000, $750,000, $750,000, $750,000, $750,000, $750,000, $750,000, $750,000, $750,000, $750,000, $750,000, $750,000, $750,000, $750,000,
It’s a girl! First foal by 2018 Triple Crown winner Justify born at Kentucky farm
- Winner of the Triple Crown The owner of Amaroo Farm near Lexington, Audley Farm, revealed on Facebook that Justify’s first reported foal was born on Friday at the farm. And it’s a filly, at that! According to Bloodhorse, the first recognized Justify foal is also the first born to mare Foreign Affair, who was acquired by Audley Farm when pregnant with the filly and boarded in Lexington while the filly was being raised. There were various suggestions for names for the infant on the Facebook post that announced the news, including “Justifiable Starz,” “Just Jamboree,” “Justifiable Affair,” and “Jolene, like the Dolly Parton song,” among others. You may also be interested in: This productive stallion has sired nearly 1,000 foals in his career. Taking a look back: Justify leaves are racing for greener pastures despite being unbeaten. The bay filly has markings that are identical to her father’s, including a white blaze that covers her forehead and nostrils. In an interview with Bloodhorse, Audley Farm equine manager Jamie McDiarmid said the filly would soon relocate to the farm, which is located in Virginia and was the home of America’s first Triple Crown champion, Sir Barton, back in 1919. Justify retired in 2018 as the only undefeated Triple Crown winner and spent his first year as a stud at Coolmore’s Ashford Stud, which is owned by the breeding powerhouse Coolmore. In 2020, Justify’s breeding cost is advertised at $150,000 by Coolmore Farms. The young filly is the first of its kind, but she will most certainly not be the last. According to the Jockey Club, Justify produced 252 mares in 2019. Only one other horse, Mendelssohn, came close to matching that total. Emma Austin, a trending reporter for Gannett, can be reached at [email protected] Follow her on Twitter, where she goes by the handle @emmacaustin.
Justify Failed a Drug Test Before Winning the Triple Crown (Published 2019)
Before winning the Triple Crown in 2018, Justify was disqualified from the Kentucky Derby after failing a post-race drug test in the Santa Anita Derby, which was one of the final preparation races for the Kentucky Derby. Credit. The New York Times’ Emma Howells contributed to this report. In the 150th running of the Belmont Stakes on June 9, 2018, a colt called Justify stormed home to thunderous applause from a sold-out crowd to earn the Triple Crown in horse racing, one of the most illustrious sporting accomplishments of all time.
- Only a few of people were aware of the secret that Baffert was carrying into the winner’s circle that day: Justify had failed a drug test only weeks before the Kentucky Derby, the first race in the Triple Crown.
- According to records seen by The New York Times, this was not the case at all.
- The board then took a series of decisions behind closed doors, rather than filing a public complaint as it normally would, as it proceeded to dismiss the case and reduce the punishment for any horse discovered to have the prohibited chemical that Justify tested positive for in its system.
- Image Photograph courtesy of Victor J.
- The failed drug test came shortly after Justify won the Santa Anita Derby.
- Scopolamine is a forbidden chemical that veterinarians believe can improve performance, especially in the amounts found in the horse.
- He finished first in the Santa Anita Derby and qualified for the Kentucky Derby.
All of it, however, did not occur.
Featured image courtesy of Victor J.
Four months later — and more than two months after Justify, Baffert, and the horse’s owners celebrated their Triple Crown triumph in New York — the board decided to dismiss the investigation entirely during a closed-door executive session with no public hearing.
The complaint was dismissed unanimously by the board of directors.
Baffert did not reply to many efforts to reach him for this article despite repeated attempts to do so.
“Environmental contamination” is frequently invoked as an excuse by regulators, according to him.
“It’s possible that we’ll wind up in Superior Court,” he remarked.
That’s not impossible, but it would have been negligent and hazardous of us to advise an investigator that something that normally takes two months must be completed in five or eight days, as opposed to the typical two months.
The records seen by The Times do not reveal any indication of pressure or meddling on the part of Justify’s proprietors.
Chuck Winner, the head of the California Horse Racing Board, holds a stake in a number of horses trained by Baffert and his associates.
In addition to power brokers in the sport, Justify’s owners included the Kentucky-based WinStar Farm, which is owned by Kenny Troutt, a billionaire commercial thoroughbred breeder; the mysterious China Horse Club, which has 200 members from mainland China and beyond who have paid a one-million-dollar membership fee; and an equine investment fund with ties to billionaire investor George Soros.
- He has five Kentucky Derby victories on his credit.
- When it came to Justify, Baffert was dealing with a horse that was late in his development and had not raced as a 2-year-old.
- Blood and urine samples from Justify and the other 34 horses that participated on the day of the Santa Anita Derby were transported to a lab at the University of California, Davis on April 10 as is typical in the horse racing industry.
- Scopolamine is often used to treat stomach or intestinal disorders in humans, including as nausea and muscular spasms.
- Associated Press photographer Jae C.
- Drug tests have shown the presence of frog and cobra venom, Viagra, cocaine, heart medications, and steroids, among other substances.
- From 2011 to 2018, Dr.
- He says the substance scopolamine can help horses breathe easier by optimizing their heart rate, which makes them faster and more efficient.
- “I believe it must be the result of deliberate involvement,” he explained.
- Arthur explained at the time.
Arthur wrote in an email circulated to Baedeker, the board’s executive director, its lawyers, and its interim chief investigator on April 20, two days after learning of Justify’s positive test result, that the case would be “handled differently than usual.” Baedeker, the board’s executive director, its lawyers, and its interim chief investigator were all copied on the email.
- In an interview, Baedeker, speaking on Dr.
- Arthur was referring to the fact that the inquiry needed to be comprehensive.
- Associated Press photographer Jae C.
- During a surveillance operation in March, an employee of a horse trainer, William Morey, was captured on video providing an illegal substance to a horse.
- Justify tested positive for scopolamine on April 26, four days before he was scheduled to go to Louisville, Ky., for the Kentucky Derby.
- The rightful Baffert requested that a second sample from that test be sent to a recognized independent lab, which was granted.
- (Justify had already won the Derby, the first leg of the Triple Crown, by that point.) The next day, Baedeker told the board members that Justify had tested positive for scopolamine, which was the cause of his arrest.
investigations section, and a hearing will be arranged,” he informed them in a note acquired by The New York Times.
Image courtesy of the Associated Press/Morry Gash The Justify case was presented directly to the California Horse Racing Board commissioners in a secret executive session on Aug.
The board of directors unanimously decided not to pursue the matter against Baffert any further.
A written response from Baedeker suggested that a small number of other horses may have been contaminated, but he provided little evidence to support his claim.
The California Racing Board, as well as the horse racing business as a whole, has come under pressure as a result of the deaths of 30 racehorses at Santa Anita Park since December 26, according to reports.
Featured image courtesy of Christian Hansen of The New York Times.
Other than Baffert, with whom the chairman has an owner-trainer connection, the board’s vice chairwoman, Madeline Auerbach, and another commissioner, Dennis Alfieri, both work as trainers and jockeys in the state of California.
In the opinion of Gorajec, who previously served as the executive director of the Indiana Horse Racing Commission, “minimal prohibitions should be placed in place to prevent active horse owners, trainers, breeders, and jockeys or anyone else who derives income from the business” from serving on a commission.
- According to Baedeker, regulators had been considering a move to the lower standard for some time.
- “We acknowledge that our staff failed to bring those changes to the board’s attention,” he said.
- The board of directors investigated him after seven horses in his care died over a 16-month period in 2013.
- While Baffert admitted to the investigators that he believed the medication would help his horses “build up,” the investigators noted that the medication is generally associated with weight loss.
- A single mating can bring in up to $150,000 for Coolmore, the international breeding company that purchased Justify’s breeding rights.
- Coolmore has already recouped its $60 million investment, indicating a successful investment.
In the meantime, Justify is in Australia. In the hope of obtaining what is supposed to be the perfect seed from the perfect racehorse, owners have their mares lined up in the vicinity. Image courtesy of Charlie Riedel of the Associated Press.
Triple Crown winner Justify is retired because of an ankle injury
Justify, the Triple Crown champion who exploded into the horse racing world in February, has vanished almost as fast as he arrived. It took just 112 racing days and six races for the 3-year-old horse to become the first and only Triple Crown champion to be undefeated in the history of the sport on Wednesday. Several people had speculated that the announcement would come in the form of a press release from WinStar Farm, the main owner of the colt. According to trainer Bob Baffert, “Justify had some filling in his ankle, and he is just not reacting quickly enough to be ready for a fall campaign.” In the end, it is my obligation to ensure that Justify performs to his fullest potential.” “I can’t make a decision until I have 60-90 days.” Immediately following Saturday’s parade in front of the Del Mar audience, Justify will make his way back to WinStar.
- It will be his third such ceremonial jog, having previously participated in similar events at Churchill Downs and Santa Anita Racetrack.
- It is estimated that the purchasing price will be in the $75-million area.
- In the end, his worth as a stallion outweighed the risk of exposing him to another season of racing, especially given his ankle condition.
- Everyone expected him to terminate his career in the Breeders’ Cup Classic, but that was not to be the case in the end.
- We are looking forward to introducing him to our supporters starting in the middle of August, once he has become used to the environment.” Justify is only the second of 13 Triple Crown winners to finish their careers with a victory in the Belmont Stakes.
- Count Fleet, on the other hand, had already completed 21 races at the time.
- ‘The fact that Justify has only had six career starts will no likely be considered as a drawback in the eyes of many when it comes to his status among the all-time greats,’ said racing historian Jon White.
According to the New York Times, “Justify’s lack of experience racing against older horses, in contrast to fellow Triple Crown victor American Pharoah, will be held against him by many.” On the other hand, the fact that Justify retires with a sense of invincibility is a bonus for the movie.
Justify competed against 35 horses, shattering the previous record of 32 horses set by War Admiral (1932).
When asked about his tolerance for individuals, Baffert replied at the Belmont that it is “roughly five seconds.” He arrived to Baffert a little later than the majority of the horses.
Baffert saw that he had something remarkable and stepped into the office of Rick Hammerle, the racing secretary at Santa Anita, before his first race to inquire whether a maiden race would have enough horses to be run.
“I have a horse who I believe has a chance to win the Kentucky Derby,” Baffert told Hammerle.
Image credit: Associated Press Photographer Mark Lennihan He won his first race at Santa Anita by 912 lengths, despite the fact that he did not have an especially nice ride from his jockey, Jose Ortiz.
“Like everyone else, I’m unhappy that he won’t be running again, but I’m grateful that he came into my life,” Smith expressed gratitude for having met the politician.
In the end, there were no horses that could keep up with him without sacrificing themselves, and there were no horses who could catch up with him.” After one race, Justify had earned such a good reputation that Baffert and Walden informed everyone that he would be running in the Sunland Derby in New Mexico in order not to frighten away horses from an allowance event at Santa Anita.
- In the end, Justify stayed home and won by 61 and a half lengths.
- It was then on to Churchill Downs for the Kentucky Derby, which took place the following day.
- Justify had little trouble overcoming the field of 20 despite running on a slick track, winning by a margin of 212.
- He was diagnosed with a small hoof bruising and was scheduled to compete in the Preakness Stakes.
- Smith said that he was aware that he had won the race and that he had eased off the horse at the conclusion.
- Three weeks later, he landed in New York, where he was greeted with all of the pomp and circumstance that the city is known for.
- It was then planned to run Justify in one or two prep races, both on the East Coast, before the Breeders’ Cup Classic at Churchill Downs on Nov.
He has one more public appearance scheduled on Saturday at Del Mar at around 3:45 p.m. It will, without a doubt, be a heartfelt farewell. UPDATES: 3:30 p.m.: The last call of the day. This page is always being updated. The original version of this item was published at 12:15 p.m.
Officials worked secretly to clear Bob Baffert’s Justify amid 2018 Triple Crown run, records show
A review of the legal papers, which include hundreds of email exchanges and other documents that have not before been made public, reveals how authorities delayed action while also contradicting their own intentions and rewriting existing regulations to Baffert’s advantage. When it came to hunting for exonerating evidence, the regulators had to go as far as to dig through a real haystack. After his horse Medina Spirit won the Kentucky Derby this year, trainer Bob Baffert was under to unprecedented scrutiny after a failed drug test was returned.
- After winning the Santa Anita Derby in April 2018, Justify was found to have tested positive with scopolamine, an anti-nausea medicine that has been linked to potential performance-enhancing effects in horses.
- However, the outcome of the canceled test remained a secret until it was revealed by the New York Times in 2019.
- Following the release of the test results, Mick Ruis, the trainer and owner of the runner-up in the Santa Anita Derby, filed a lawsuit against the CHRB, arguing that Justify’s victory should have been overturned.
- In his brief, the state’s attorney stated that a court might “find that the CHRB misused its authority and proceeded in a way that was either arbitrary, capricious, or completely devoid of evidentiary evidence.” According to an email from Baffert’s attorney, W.
- “There is nothing new to be found here,” he stated.
- Rick Baedeker, who served as executive director of the CHRB until his retirement last year, stated that the board’s actions were carefully studied in order to avoid treating Baffert differently than any other trainer in the industry.
- The unusual treatment did not have anything to do with the horse’s trainer, even though he acknowledged that the issue had been treated differently because of the Triple Crown implications.
“The way this issue was handled was not in Bob Baffert’s favor,” Arthur stated emphatically. “It was done out of respect for Justify that this matter was handled the way it was.”
A retroactive rule change
A positive scopolamine test for Justify and another Baffert horse, called Hoppertunity, was discovered in the afternoon of April 18, 2018, and Arthur was informed as a result. Arthur and Baffert had already had a convoluted relationship for some years by that point. According to a story in the Washington Post last month, Arthur had previously investigated a string of untimely horse fatalities at Baffert’s stable. He was doing so at the same time that a political organization with Baffert on its board of directors was participating in legislation that would result in Arthur losing his job.
(“The activities were completely unconnected,” Arthur and those engaged with the bill stated.) In the early stages of the Justify case, according to the documents, Arthur’s actions caused the CHRB to deviate from its typical course of action, beginning with an email to a testing coordinator that stated, “The scopolamine cases will be handled differently than usual.” It was apparent, according to the CHRB’s own standards, that if the second sample came back positive, the CHRB would file a complaint with the Department of Justice.
In every situation in which a split sample supports the initial laboratory report, according to an alert posted on the CHRB website, a complaint is lodged.
If the complaint had been resolved in a timely manner, Justify would have been disqualified from competing in the Kentucky Derby.
In the words of Arthur, “This horse was supposed to compete in the Triple Crown.” To top CHRB officials, Arthur stated in an email, “We have a genuine problem to work out,” saying that he considered a disqualification would be “terribly unjust.” It had already been more than a year since the Association of Racing Commissioners International (ARCI), which develops model rules for use by the sport’s different state authorities, had downgraded scopolamine from its previous classification of “3/B” to “4/C.” A 4/C breach resulted in a small punishment that did not usually include disqualification of the horse or redistributing prizes to the owners.
- That suggestion had not been approved by the CHRB.
- For Arthur, the new categorization just makes more sense in the context of pharmaceutical research.
- According to CHRB rules, the state board’s foreign substances standards are “based on” ARCI recommendations that have been “updated.” As ARCI president Ed Martin said in an interview, the regulations are “recommendations” rather than rules themselves.
- However, in this particular case, Arthur argued for a less severe punishment based on his request that the CHRB degrade the medicine.
Arthur, who worked as a racetrack veterinarian before becoming medical equine director, stated, “I feel there is some precedence in criminal law when a statute is changed from a felony to a misdemeanor how they should be punished even before the new legislation goes effective.” The CHRB’s top brass agreed to adopt Arthur’s recommendation.
Because “our staff was unable to act in a timely manner,” Baedeker said in a letter to the agency’s counsel that if they did not adopt the more lenient classification, “the horses, trainer, owner, and others may have been unfairly damaged.”
Searching for Jimson weed
As the Kentucky Derby neared, officials began to speculate about the likelihood of “contamination,” or the chance that Justify’s positive test had been caused by anything he had consumed before the race. Scopolamine, according to Baedeker, “may be administered orally, although it is more frequently the result of feed or straw that has been tainted with Jimson weed.” Jimson weed contamination had previously been dismissed as a severe concern by Arthur, who wrote in a 2016 report that the “chance of receiving a positive result from environmental contamination is relatively low” under the present testing techniques.
When asked about the incident this week, Arthur clarified that he meant that such occurrences were unusual, but said that in California, “if you’re scopolamine positive, it’s going to be connected with Jimson cannabis — that’s simply the reality of the situation.” According to documents, on April 26, Arthur wrote CHRB officials to advise them that he had “spoken to Bob” and that the procedures would not interfere with Justify’s Triple Crown schedule immediately.
- “I informed him that there would be no new material from CHRB before the Kentucky Derby, that it would be improbable before the Preakness, and that it might not be available until after the Belmont,” Arthur wrote.
- In the course of his investigation for Jimson marijuana, a CHRB investigator discovered a leafy substance at Santa Anita Park, according to the papers, and following the Derby, Arthur and the CHRB’s counsel agreed to have it tested.
- Baedeker confirmed last week that they had handled the procedure more slowly than they had in the past.
- The search for Jimson marijuana went on for a little longer.
- In accordance with CHRB records, Larry Bell, the owner of Citrus Feed Company, has long been a supplier to Baffert and has previously testified in Baffert’s defense on several occasions.
- Bell told an investigator that he then went through the rest of the bales and discovered a branch and pods that he believed to be Jimson weed in the parking lot.
- Jimson marijuana was, in fact, the drug in question.
- A complaint against Baffert had been indicated by CHRB officials during the months-long investigation, which would have made the failed drug test public knowledge.
- However, by August, the strategy had shifted.
- The board decided to go along with their advice.
In Baedeker’s opinion, “we would’ve been dumping this on their laps, putting them in an unfair situation,” and “we needed to go ahead and do the hardest thing, quite honestly, which is to accept responsibility for the choice.” Ruis filed a lawsuit against the CHRB in January 2020, after the New York Times reported the story of the adverse drug test.
- On July 15, 2020, Deputy Attorney General Robert Petersen sent Brodnik his “initial case assessment,” which is a preliminary assessment of the case.
- However, he claimed that it was not evident from the documents why the CHRB changed its mind about submitting a complaint against Baffert in the first place.
- However, even in those instances when the horses were disqualified and their winning purses were forfeited, the cases were handled in accordance with established standards.
- David Arthur, the CHRB’s equine medical director, expressed his disagreement with Petersen’s legal conclusion that the CHRB’s handling of the matter might be considered arbitrary or capricious.
- On Wednesday, he will complete his tenure as medical equine director.
- to proceed with the recommendation.” A request for an interview with Petersen went unanswered.
- Almost immediately after Petersen provided the state’s odds analysis, the CHRB decided to settle Ruis’s complaint with the state.
- In an October hearing, the state, counsel for Baffert, and the horses’ owners all agreed that the scopolamine positive was the product of contamination and that it would have no performance-enhancing impact on the horses’ performance.
- Baffert’s attorney brought as a defense witness Arthur, who claimed that his handling of the issue was the fault of “California’s complex regulatory procedure.” Baffert was found not guilty of any charges.
- Following the hearing, the accusations were dismissed by the Board of Stewards of Santa Anita, a three-member body that adjudicates on drug matters.
But the stewards hinted that they would not have reached the same conclusion as the CHRB: “It is the Stewards’ judgment that, had this Board of Stewards received the accusations against Justify and Hoppertunity prior to August 23, 2018, both horses would have been disqualified.” Ruis’s attorneys have since claimed in court that the settlement should be revoked “since the stewards declined to make a judgement on the merits of the case.” “I am confident that justice has not yet been done,” Vienna said in an interview with The Washington Post, “and that the courts will hopefully conclude the situation.” More information may be found at:
Justify’s retirement a sign of the times
Increasingly as the Kentucky Derby neared, authorities began to debate the prospect of “contamination,” or the potential that Justify’s positive test was prompted by anything other than the horse’s urine. As Baedeker put it, “Scopopolamine” can be administered by an injection, although it’s most typically the result of feed or straw that has been infected with Jimsonweed. Jimson weed contamination had previously been dismissed as a severe concern by Arthur, who wrote in a 2016 report that the “chance of receiving a positive result from environmental contamination is relatively low” under the present testing protocols.
“I informed him that there would be no new material from CHRB before the Kentucky Derby, that it was unlikely to be released before the Preakness, and that it was possible that it would not be released until after the Belmont.” “I informed him that I believed there was a strong indication that these were the result of feed contamination,” says the author.
- According to the papers, a CHRB detective on the lookout for Jimson cannabis came up a leafy material at Santa Anita Park, and following the Derby, Arthur and the CHRB’s counsel agreed to have it tested for the presence of the drug.
- Baedeker stated last week that they had handled the procedure more slowly than they had been used to doing.
- After then, the search for Jimson marijuana was on!
- In accordance with CHRB records, Larry Bell, president of Citrus Feed Company, has long been a supplier to Baffert and has previously testified in his defense.
- The next day, Bell told an investigator, he searched additional bales and discovered a branch and pods that he believed to be Jimson weed in the parking lot of the warehouse.
- Jimson marijuana was, in fact, the drug.
- A complaint against Baffert was expected to be filed by CHRB authorities during the months-long investigation, which would have made the failed drug test publicly available.
However, by August, the original concept had been scrapped altogether.
According to the state’s legal analysis, Baedeker and Arthur advised that “the outstanding proceedings against Baffert be dropped.” The board of directors acted on their advice.
“I felt like we would’ve been dumping this on their shoulders, that we would’ve been putting them in an unfair situation, and that we needed to go ahead and do the hardest thing, quite honestly, which was to accept responsibility for the choice,” Baedeker said.
In his lawsuit, he alleged that the board’s “cover up” resulted in him losing damages of $400,000, which included the difference between first and second place payouts in the Santa Anita Derby.
According to Petersen, punishing Baffert for what he termed “an mistake by CHRB personnel” would have been “unfair,” and there is “no evidence to infer a sinister purpose” on the part of the board, according to the attorney.
According to the attorney, there is “material showing that this incident was handled in a different manner.” He pointed out that in a prior case, the board had found that three horses who had tested positive for scopolamine had flunked their tests as a result of Jimson weed and exonerated their trainers.
- The chances of the state winning at trial, according to Petersen’s research, are 50 percent.
- Arthur, who announced his retirement this year, added, “Other individuals may have reached a different conclusion, but to claim that there was no foundation for that conclusion is plain bulls-.” On Wednesday, he will retire from his position as medical equine director.
- to proceed with the process.” Following an interview request, Petersen did not react.
- The CHRB decided to settle Ruis’s complaint shortly after Petersen provided his assessment of the state’s chances.
- According to the state and counsel for Baffert and the horses’ owners at a hearing held in October, the scopolamine positive was the product of contamination and had no performance-enhancing benefits.
- Baffert’s attorney presented as a defense witness Arthur, who claimed that his handling of the issue was the fault of “California’s complex regulatory procedure.” Baffert was found not guilty of the charges.
- Following the hearing, the accusations were dismissed by the Board of Stewards of Santa Anita, a three-member body that adjudicates drug matters.
The stewards, on the other hand, indicated that they would not have reached the same conclusion as the CHRB: “It is the Stewards’ judgment that, had this Board of Stewards received the Justify and Hoppertunity allegations prior to August 23, 2018, both horses would have been disqualified.” It has now been contended in court that the settlement should be reversed “because the stewards refused to make an informed decision on the merits.” In an interview with The Washington Post, Vienna stated that “I am still certain that justice has not yet been served” and expressed optimism that the subject will be resolved in court.
For further information, please see this link: